Swallowing My Own Medicine

Sage advice for singles who have ever uttered the phrase, “My parish only cares about married couples and families.”
I had to swallow a big dose of my own medicine today, and it didn’t taste very good.  It’s easy to dole out advice to other singles when life is more-or-less put together!  My life has basically been turned upside-down the past 6 months. The result of which has left me searching for a new spiritual home.  Needless to say, it’s been a bit of an adjustment.

Given the demographics of my northside Chicago neighborhood, it would be easy to find a church with a large percentage of single people – even if that meant a little longer commute to Mass on Sunday morning.  It would be even easier for me to continuously “shop around” – hopping from one church to the next, week after week, without ever making a commitment to one particular church community.  Consistency and accountability are important to me, so church-hopping was not an option.  I had a few basic criteria (good preaching, decent music), but more than anything I wanted to find a church community close to home.

So, for the time being, I’ve landed at a large family friendly neighborhood parish.  It’s a short drive (or a long walk) impeded only by multiple one-way streets.  There is a sense of community and diversity that I find incredibly attractive.  The pastor is outgoing and personable; he remembers names and goes out of his way to introduce people to one another.  It’s not perfect (no place is), but it is a place that I find myself drawn to week after week.

Lately, however, I have found myself repeating that often-voiced single person’s complaint:  My parish only cares about married couples and families.  I never imagined that I would use that phrase to describe my feelings about the church!

I have to admit though, there are a LOT of families at my new parish, and they are blessed with a very active religious education program and a large Catholic school.  As I look around the church on Sunday, I know that I am not the only single person.  Yet despite all that is good about this place, I regularly resist the urge to grab a red magic marker and cross off every announcement in the bulletin that is specifically designed for families and circle the one or two options that are available for singles.

It happened again today, and this time I cried.  I noticed an announcement about an upcoming church fundraiser at a local pub (with the pastor and school principal as guest bartenders, no less!).  Finally, a chance to meet people in a fun social setting!  I couldn’t wait to get home and put the date on my calendar.  Once at home, I opened the bulletin again and noticed a detail I hadn’t previously seen.  RSVPs are to be turned in to the school office, and the response form also requested “your child’s homeroom number”.

Immediately, it became clear to me that this was a social event for parents, and my heart sank.

Sure, I could email the contact person and ask if non-parents are welcome.  It would not be difficult for me walk an RSVP form over to the school office, and I could simply mark “N/A” in that spot inquiring about whether or not I have a child in the school.  Perhaps I’m being foolish for overthinking this, and maybe it’s clear to everyone else that this event is open to all parishoners.  But as a new-comer, it’s really not clear WHO is invited.

(And seriously, if it is open to everyone in the parish, then why do you need a homeroom number?!  Retired people don’t have a homeroom number … neither do single people, or young couples with babies, or couples without children, or families who choose to send their kids to public school, or older adults whose children have graduated! Argh!!! Sorry, end of rant.)

PA280024What I’m realizing, for the first time, is that community is not automatic.  Showing up for Mass is not enough.  Meeting people takes a lot of work, and truly getting to know a person takes consistent effort.  Furthermore, the fruits of those labors are not immediate.  I’ve exchanged friendly good-morning greetings with dozens of people over the past 4 months.  But knowing names does not constitute community, and seeing the same person three weeks in a row does not make you friends.

The perfectionist in me, the part of me that hates being a beginner, quickly grows frustrated.  I keep telling myself that those with a vocation to the single life have a unique role to play in the church.  In theory, I believe this.  In reality, I’m struggling to know how to do this.  At one point, I even thought, “someone should really write a book about … oh, yea… this.”

So, it’s time to swallow some of my own medicine on the subject.


Years ago, my wise older sister and her family moved to a new city, and she developed 3 simple criteria in their search for a new parish – prayer, participation, and presence.  I think the same criteria applies to singles looking to find their place in a family-friendly parish.

1. PRAYER: Is this a place where I can pray well and feel connected to God?  Do I experience God’s presence in the physical space, as well as during the liturgical celebration?

I have to remind myself that church is not about what I get out of it – this isn’t a concert! It’s not about “feeling good” when I leave.  The purpose of our communal prayer is to give glory and praise to God!  We praise God by our singing, by our active participation, by our attentive listening, by greeting one another with a sign of hospitality upon entering, by sharing with one another a sign of Christ’s peace, by receiving Christ reverently in the Eucharist.  We praise God in all these ways.

So, as a single person, how do I praise God when I am constantly distracted by the chatter of small children?

Well, I certainly have a much greater appreciation for family dynamics after spending time with my siblings and their kids!  I’ve been the doting aunt standing at the back of church with a two-year-old who cannot sit still.  And it’s given me a tremendous amount of compassion for parents who are raising their children in the church.

Perhaps my greatest gift as a single person is to welcome, acknowledge, and empower the presence of families – especially those for whom Sunday morning can be a struggle.

Last week, I was well aware of the family of four sitting behind me.  Yet, despite their fair share of squirming and parental hushing, these two grade-school aged youngsters belted out every single word of the Lord’s Prayer with tremendous gusto!  (I found it delightfully humorous, because they reminded me so much of my nephews!)  At the sign of peace, one parent politely apologized for their kids’ antics.  I don’t remember my response, but I’m sure it was something like, “You have a beautiful family, and I’m really glad you’re here!”

Finally, I have to admit that I much prefer extended periods of silent prayer – which is not always possible at a busy parish on Sunday morning.  So, I experiment with different mass times.  I take advantage of time spent at home reading the Sunday scriptures.  Being in a large city, I know the secret hiding places where I can find a quiet prayer space during the week.  Sunday morning liturgy isn’t about me (see comments above); it’s about “us” being the body of Christ together.  The more I attend to my need for quiet time and personal prayer, the better I am able to be joyfully present and appreciative of our entire church family on Sunday.

2. PARTICIPATION: Does the church welcome participation in the liturgy, especially from women, children, lay people, families, single people, young adults, new comers, etc.? Are there opportunities for fellowship, catechesis, faith-sharing, social justice programs, etc.?  Is this a place where I could see myself participating in some way? 

I gave a presentation for singles at a parish several years ago.  During the Q&A, a woman raised her hand and insisted “there is nothing here for singles.”  I was grateful that the Director of Faith Formation was in the room.  She quickly pointed out that most events were open to the entire parish and very few things were exclusively for couples.  Sometimes, it is really a matter of perception.

I find that I need to be brutally honest about what I notice.  As I glance through the Sunday bulletin, the options for families are quickly apparent – religious education for children, a monthly family mass, marriage retreats, a spotlight on one of the teachers.  Sometimes my bitterness makes me blind, and I miss what’s right there in front of me – a book club, bible study, women’s group, food pantry volunteers, garden club, music ministry, a pilgrimage, retreat programs, etc..  If you find yourself saying there is “nothing” here for singles, look again.  Or better yet, look for opportunities to create something for singles.

3. PRESENCE: Am I called from here to be the presence of Christ for others? Are there opportunities for outreach to the community, the poor, and the wider church? 

It’s tempting for me to look at my current situation and say, “I’m not getting anything out of this” and go someplace else.  But then, I know I would be missing out on everything this great multi-generational church has to teach me.  And to be honest, they would be missing out on what a generous single woman like me has to give!  Being new, I sometimes have to remind myself of the most basic things:

Show up!  Do something that requires no commitment other than to be present.  Donuts and coffee after mass is a great example.  It doesn’t get any easier than this!  Grab a cup of coffee, say hello to people, and trust that God is at work in bringing you together.  Building community takes time, but you have to take the first step.

Volunteer!  The possibilities are endless: the food pantry, the choir, bible study, visiting the homebound.  Meet people, ask their names, ask if they live in the area, and ask how long they’ve been members here.  In turn, share something about yourself and give people a chance to get to know YOU.

Remember, you belong here!  The body of Christ includes all of us!  That’s true for men, women, children, teens, families, single parents, widows, divorced, vowed religious, gay, straight, people of all racial and ethnic backgrounds, the uber-pious, the biker gang members (yes, there was a tattooed motorcycle gang at church a few weeks ago!), believers, beginners, the hopeful, the doubtful, the lost and the found, all of us!

Each person brings a unique set of gifts, life experiences, ways of prayer … and single people in particular, at whatever age and stage in life, bring a unique vantage point.

I guess the primary reason I’m committed to staying here is because I can answer YES to those three questions.  Yes, I pray well there – it is a beautiful space, where I continue to feel drawn in.  Yes, I participate there – and I’m especially looking forward to the garden club convening again this spring!  Yes, I’m called forth to be Christ’s presence from there.

If you ask me where I experience the presence of Christ most profoundly these days, it’s at the dining room table (an altar of sorts?) of my best friends – where we have shared copious amounts of bread and wine, simple home-cooked meals, endless cups of coffee, and a lot of gelato!  My friends are endlessly exhausted with raising 3 kids under the age of three.  Their constant refrain is, “It really does take a village, and we’re so grateful that you’re part of ours….”

The “church” I experience in their home is messy, imperfect, filled with laughter, and sometimes interrupted by a toddler announcing she needs to use the potty.  My best friend’s willingness to listen, ask tough questions, and her ability to accept me for who I am is unsurpassed!  We don’t expect each other to be perfect, and we manage to bring out the best in each other even on our worst days.

The time I spend with my friends reminds me that the presence of Christ which I experience on Sunday in this beautiful, imperfect, holy place called “church” truly does prepare me for being and experiencing the presence of Christ in the world.

5 thoughts on “Swallowing My Own Medicine”

  1. The part where you mentioned someone should write a book about it cracked me up!

    But seriously, thanks for putting this out there. I think it’s important for us single people to remember we still have a role in our churches, but it’s also important for the churches to remember that we are out there, that sometimes we shy away because we feel unwelcomed, even if that’s not the church’s intention. A hand stretched out to welcome the single person would be greatly appreciated!

  2. What a gift from God you are! Thank you so much for you candid and heart felt sharing and reflection. Thanks for pointing to the heart of Church and challenging everyone to be intentional about Church! You are a gift! Keep sharing.

  3. You are inspiring to so many! I really enjoyed this post and hope you don’t mind my sisterly reflections as I wind down my Sunday evening:

    Moving to a new parish is kind of like moving to a new community and even though I’ve only moved a few times as an adult (each time was across the country), I always think it takes about 1-2 years to adjust and really feel “at home”. The same goes with finding a new parish! What’s funny is that when we’ve moved, so many said to us, “You know so many people already!” and “I feel like you’ve lived here for years!” Why? Because we made a conscious effort to put ourselves out there, meet people, get involved … we are placed in the world to LOVE (something you do so well, Beth!) When we show love in our parishes, by giving of ourselves generously and with good, selfless intentions; that is when we begin to feel Christ working within us and through us. Whether or not that love is reciprocated is not what is as important as being Christ to others and seeking His face in those we come into contact with on the journey.

    I seem to remember the conversation we had about finding a parish (way, way, back when) and also conversing about “Presence” being the presence of Jesus in the Eucharist as well. What’s great about the Catholic church, is that no matter which parish you call home, HE will always be there waiting for you! Yet, so many of us seek to find a “holy experience” in the music, the preaching and yes, the people (which are all good and nice to have)… those are all temporary things that can and often over time will change. Leadership or administration changes, priests get re-assigned, funding decreases or increases, people come and go and even our own expectations change, but, isn’t it so incredibly wonderful to know that no matter what is going on within the church or within our own lives, we can go to Mass and receive Christ.

    I would expect that whether one is single or married, a young adult or more “seasoned” parishioner, that we all find ourselves wanting the experience of the Mass or the expectations of our parish life to be better or different. I for one longed for a Mass where I could enjoy silence without being interrupted (in loud, outdoor voices) by my children and then I would sob all the way home thanks to the embarrassment I felt I experienced because of it. (Even the married folks can feel like the odd man out.) Over time I learned to turn these tense moments (like of books being thrown by toddlers two pews behind us) in church into moments of patience, joy and just plain “par for the course”. Thankfully, after 3 rambunctious boys, God gave us one MORE … just so I could have the opportunity to fully redeem myself and give me one more shot at “getting this one right.” And, just like you have done for others in this situation, I SO RELISHED THOSE TIMES when that one person would commend my efforts and say how nice it was that I was bringing my kids to Mass.

    And, I too would long for ministries that perhaps would cater to my particular stage in life. Of course I learned that when one talks about what’s missing, that person ends up being the person who gets to spearhead the next new ministry, fundraiser or speaker series. I’ve now learned to keep my mouth shut! (Ha, ha!)

    I smiled when I started reading your post because I KNEW you knew the answers, Beth! You answered your own questions beautifully. And, it seems you’ve learned that the best place to find Christ is in the “Domestic Church” after all … in someone’s home, in a place where “family” is present, where love abounds and where all life’s messes can be cleaned up through intentionally living the Gospel message.

    Love you!

  4. While reading the daily inspiration and prayer from my Midwest Jesuit app this morning, I found your blog link. Interesting how God’s Grace leads us to discernment. I so often don’t realize grace led me until I arrive! I am here. I am ill as is your optimistic and grace filled friend but with Lupus rather than cancer. I shall pray for him.

    And, I moved to a new church just as I became ill. I wasn’t getting any of your thoughtfully, prayerfully put together list at my old church, sadly. I gave a lot to it. Now ill and more alone, I found myself pulled constantly to a new church. I moved but I don’t YET have the friends and support I got from my last church, especially because I am too ill to attend. I am lucky that I have friends from my last church for support, lucky I have my husband, andI look forward to my infusions working so I may begin seeing what God pulls me to find at my new church. It is always a tough move!

    I am not single but, for reasons he will reconcile with God, I know, my husband has never attended church with me. It is hard being “single” even when one isn’t. I am praying for you and I hope you will pray for me. God brings our greatest gifts at our lowest points, so often.

    At my last church I began to form groups of women who were single, literally, and single for church as I. I hope you might discuss doing the same. I was surprised how many husbands don’t come, at how easy it was to make friends in a study or a prayer group or a twice a month lunch meetings. We often began with 2 only to grow to many…or none. But it is from those groups that I made friends with women who now support me, lift me, pray for me. Such creative, inclusive, prayerful ways to serve God and God’s people came from us and we met for fellowship, too, with men! I love the idea of having the priest serve. I can’t wait to reach remission to start over again at a new church, although I am a bit frightened, too. I often think that I chose a silly time to change churches but 3 years on, I am beginning to understand. This isn’t my timing or choice. It is God’s.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s